Situationship vs. Friends with Benefits: What Is the Difference?

Modern dating labels can get quite confusing, so if you’re unsure about the difference between being in a situationship vs. friends with benefits, you are not alone. While getting to know someone romantically can be enjoyable, it can also be frustrating not to know what your relationship is. Understanding the difference between these two terms is vital for one’s emotional well-being.

If you don’t feel encouraged to ask the other person about it, certain clues can help you have a better picture. In this article, we have taken a closer look at the rise of situationships and friends-with-benefits dynamics and outlined the key differences.

Definition of Situationship

Situationship is more than just dating, yet it is less than a relationship. Both sides can be emotionally intimate without committing. Unlike in traditional relationships, two people in a situationship have ambiguous expectations and inconsistent communication. They meet spontaneously or occasionally, as they don’t see themselves as a couple that needs to foster intimacy.

Choosing to be in a situationship can be due to avoiding commitment or fulfilling intimate needs without the pressure to define the relationship. You might have a busy schedule or be focused on goals in other life areas, which makes a situationship a perfect recipe to get what you need without complications or stress. Sometimes, being in a situationship can also be a sign of past trauma, which makes it difficult for the person to emotionally connect to another person on a deeper level. However, there is a risk that situational relationships will be seen as too uncertain, painful, or even frustrating for those who wish to take this arrangement to the next stage.

Definition of Friends with Benefits

You can be in a situationship with a person you have just met or someone you already know. A typical example can be a friend of a friend, a coworker, or a person you’ve met in a bar. However, friends with benefits implies there was a friendship before it turned into something else. The foundation between two people is still friendship with a new layer added, which is a consensual sexual relationship.

When you’re friends with benefits with someone, it typically implies a clear agreement between you, including rules and boundaries. Expectations are more focused on enjoying the physical aspect of your relationship, while emotional expectations are minimal.

For friends with benefits to last, friendship must come first. This dynamic is suitable for those seeking intimacy without commitment and leveraging existing trust for comfort. Some people might enter into friends-with-benefits relationships to avoid relationship stress and emotional work. Friends with benefits can offer physical connection and closeness without the complexities and potential vulnerability of a conventional romantic relationship.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a situationship the same as friends with benefits?

A situationship usually involves emotional intimacy and unclear expectations, while friends with benefits is based on a clear agreement that prioritizes friendship and casual physical intimacy without romantic commitment.

Is a situationship more emotionally risky than friends with benefits?

Situationships are generally more emotionally risky because they lack clarity and boundaries. This is why situationships often lead to confusion, anxiety, or unbalanced attachment. Friends with benefits tend to be less risky when expectations are clearly defined and respected.

Can friends with benefits end in a situationship?

If emotional attachment develops without open communication or renegotiated boundaries, an FWB arrangement can easily turn into a situationship.

Why do situationships last so long?

Situationships often last because of fear of commitment and comfort in ambiguity. People also stay in such arrangements when they are hoping for “more” or avoiding difficult conversations. This is often the case when one person is more emotionally invested than the other.

Key Differences Between Situationships and Friends with Benefits

None of these options is better or worse; your choice will depend solely on your preferences and circumstances. However, it is important to understand the key differences between situationships and friends with benefits.

Emotional Involvement

Being in a situationship requires no emotional involvement because neither side is looking to grow together as a couple. Instead, they wish to enjoy the benefits without committing. Friends with benefits, on the other hand, will have more emotional involvement than situationships because the two people in this type of arrangement are already friends. This emotional connection arises from their pre-existing friendship, which is not romantic in nature.

Communication Clarity

Friends with benefits offers more clarity to both sides than a situationship. Because they want to preserve their friendship, friends with benefits will focus more on clear communication and expressing how they both see this arrangement. People in situationships will typically not put as much effort into clarifying the rules and needs, as they will only focus on enjoying the positive sides of this experience.

Expectations & Boundaries

Similar to communication clarity, friends will benefit from being better at defining their expectations and boundaries. It is not to say that if you are in a situationship, you are forbidden to have expectations or set a boundary; it is just less common.

Long-term Potential

No one can say which relationship will last longer, but there are signs that can indicate it. Being friends with somebody and enjoying the physical intimacy with them satisfies more needs than being in a situationship. Of course, if a person is not looking for the type of intimacy a friendship offers, they can be perfectly fine with spending years in situationships. However, the question is whether or not the other person will feel the same way as time goes by.

Power Imbalance

Typically, situationships can imply a certain level of power imbalance. One person is often more interested than the other, or their feelings develop as the situationship continues. When you are friends with benefits, both sides can have equal power in making decisions that concern them. This is due to the respect and confidence that were previously built in the friendship.

Conclusion

When comparing situationships with friends with benefits, remember that there is no wrong option. You might prefer one dynamic at a certain point in your life and find yourself drawn to another later on. As with any type of relationship we choose to form, understanding the emotional structure and expectations involved matters. This clarity can help reduce confusion or unnecessary hurt, and if you ever find yourself wanting a deeper, more personalized perspective, a thoughtful conversation with the right guide can make all the difference.

About Life Coaching and Therapy

Life Coaching and Therapy (LCAT) is a therapy and coaching practice that transforms our clients lives through our flexibility multi-technique approach and pleasure-skills training provided by systematically trained and licensed therapists!

Get to know our founder and owner, Amanda Pasciucco, (a.k.a. The Sex Healer) PhD, Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist (LMFT), and an AASECT Certified Sex Therapist (CST) who has developed innovative therapy programs and therapy videos that get results.

Our team of compassionate, licensed therapists and certified sex therapists helps all clients who visit us for a variety of personal, relationship, intimacy and sex problems.

LCAT provides on-site appointments, as well as video chat and text therapy programs.

Learn more about how LCAT can help improve your life at What We Do.